SUPPORT US
Thodoris Chondrogiannos
Ministry of Health violates the legislation on public consultation
20 • 07 • 2020

On July 6, 2020, the Ministry of Health posted a bill on the public consultation website. However, the process followed by the government violated the rules of public consultation and good legislation.

According to Article 61 paragraphs 2, 3 & 4 of the key transparency law (ν. 4622/2019 – ΦΕΚ Α’ 133/07.08.2019), “consultation on bills is done through the website www.opengov.gr and lasts two weeks,” and only exceptionally can be shortened to one week “for sufficiently substantiated reasons, referred to in the public consultation report accompanying the arrangement” which “is posted on the website where the consultation took place.”

On July 6, 2020, the Ministry of Health published on the public consultation website a bill entitled, “Arrangements to ensure access to quality health services and the establishment of the National Organisation for Quality Assurance in Health.” The consultation lasted until July 13, meaning that the government shortened the consultation period to the minimum legally permissible duration of one week.  

It should be noted that the Minister of Health, Vassilis Kikilias, added an accompanying note stating that “the public electronic consultation will last until July 13, 2020 at 8 p.m. due to the urgent need for a speedy settlement of these issues.” However, this note does not make reference to the ‘sufficiently substantiated reasons’ for shortening the consultation, as required by law.

Where is the problem with the Rule of Law?

In a state that adheres to the rule of law, the government strictly follows the rules of good legislation, as this presupposes the improvement of legislative work and addresses the negative consequences of bad legislative practices (such as, for example, the multiplicity and incomprehensibility of provisions that have built up over time in Greek legislation). 

Furthermore, the implementation of the rules of good legislation contributes to the consolidation of citizens’ trust in state institutions and the law, as they observe that the government complies with the law, strengthening the democratic principle where citizens and bodies of public power are equal before the law. 

This is even more true of the public consultation process, the establishment of which allows civil society to take an active part in shaping the laws that govern a democratic society. 

However, in this case, the Ministry of Health did not apply the rules regarding the length of the consultation process, limiting the ability of citizens to express their views on the proposed legislation without providing, as required by law, sufficiently substantiated reasons for doing so.

Thodoris Chondrogiannos
More
Submit a report if you have detected a violation of the rule of law!
SIGNED REPORT VIA DEDICATED FORM ON GOVWATCH
ANONYMOUS REPORT VIA GLOBALEAKS
Support govwatch
DONATE